Management is from Mars, Labor is from Venus

imageGood summary of the status quo. Allow me to add: Aside from the obvious political struggle, there is also a significant cultural difference at play here between corporate America and the German business world. One of the reasons for the adversarial nature of the U.S. labor-management disconnect is the preference of American culture on individualism and self-reliance. In the current context this clashes with Germany’s ideal of co-determination and corporate social responsibility.

This contrast has been blown up even further by protagonists on both sides of the debate: First, by conservative U.S. politicians who were reproaching Volkswagen for entering into a dialog with the UAW and basically telling the company that they don’t know how to run their business – publicly. And secondly, by senior union officials in Germany who are comparing Tennessee and the U.S. to North Korea.

Time to call in the mediators.

Business & Money

The most important labor debate in the country right now isn’t the minimum wage issue that President Obama spent so much time on in his SOTU speech this week. Rather, it is a fascinating fight that’s going on at a VW plant in Chattanooga, Tennessee, over whether or not there will be a German style “works council” at the factory, an old style branch of the U.A.W, or no organized labor movement at all.

It’s a deeply psychological fight that has created some surprising alliances and rifts, and may herald an entirely new way to think about labor relations and economic development in this country. As everyone knows, American unions and American management are like oil and water—in the U.S., shareholder capitalism has always had little regard for the ownership rights of workers, and (perhaps as a result) organized labor has always been militant and difficult. Management squeezes, and labor…

View original post 302 more words

One thought on “Management is from Mars, Labor is from Venus

  1. I saw something in the news about the comparison to North Korea, and although it may resonate with officials and the public in Germany, I don’t think it will help things (or even make sense) here in the U.S. To be fair, Americans (those who saw the news, anyway) would be just as perplexed about the labor issues at the Amazon plant in Germany, or the Goodyear Tire plant in France. I think our own national ways of doing things become so ingrained that we are startled by radically different interpretations of work, ownership, relationships, and rights within organizations. Lucky for TN that they have a German nearby to help them navigate this conflict!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s